⚖️ Ratio Decidendi & Regulatory Mandate
Section 18 SARFAESI DRAT Pre-Deposit Waiver Judicial Discretion: The Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT) has statutory discretion under the third proviso to Section 18(1) of the SARFAESI Act to reduce the mandatory pre-deposit from 50% to a minimum of 25% upon establishing genuine financial distress and bona fide grounds of appeal.
1. Regulatory Framework & Background Matrix
The appellant borrower filed an appeal before the DRAT against a recovery order of the DRT. The DRAT insisted on a strict 50% pre-deposit without considering the appellant's documented financial insolvency.
2. Statutory Interpretation & Prudential Mandate
The Supreme Court analyzed Section 18(1) and observed that while the statute requires 50% deposit as a general rule, the third proviso empowers the Appellate Tribunal, for reasons to be recorded in writing, to reduce the amount to not less than 25%. Mechanical refusal to exercise this discretion amounts to failure of statutory jurisdiction.
3. Practical Strategic Implications for Borrowers & Litigants
Litigants filing appeals under Section 18 can prevent shut-out of appellate remedy by presenting audited financial records, tax returns, and bank statements establishing impecuniosity, legally binding the DRAT to consider reducing the pre-deposit threshold to 25%.