⚖️ Ratio Decidendi (Binding Legal Principle)
Section 31(i) Agricultural Land Exemption & Total Immunity from Mortgage Enforcement: Section 31(i) prohibits creation and enforcement of security interests over agricultural land. The determination of whether land is agricultural depends on actual cultivation and revenue records, and artificial classification by banks cannot override statutory revenue status.
1. Factual Matrix & Judicial Progression
Borrower company mortgaged a luxury hotel parcel in Goa containing uncultivated agricultural plots. When the bank initiated SARFAESI auctions, the debtor claimed exemption under Section 31(i).
2. Statutory Interpretation & Bench Findings
The Supreme Court held that the purpose of Section 31(i) is to protect bona fide agriculturalists and agricultural production. Where agricultural land has been integrated into a commercial hotel resort and no actual cultivation occurs, the exemption under Section 31(i) cannot be invoked fraudulently to defeat recovery.
3. Practical Implications for Borrowers & Secured Creditors
Where rural lands are actively cultivated and recorded as agricultural in revenue records (Jamabandi / Khasra Girdawari), Section 31(i) offers an absolute statutory bar that invalidates bank mortgage creation and enforcement in toto.